# South Korea's court administration backs a fine for AI-faked case citations, citing a survey of 360 judges

Published 2026-11-02T15:42:54.000Z · AI Pulse · https://ai-pulse.news/policy-law/south-korea-courts-fine-ai-fake-citations

*This story was written with the help of artificial intelligence, checked automatically, then reviewed by an editor before publication, under our AI policy : https://ai-pulse.news/ai-policy*

South Korea's National Court Administration has published survey results based on 360 judges' replies collected from 6 to 16 October, and says legal amendments are needed to allow a fine for AI-generated false case citations.

## Key points

- The survey ran from 6 to 16 October 2026 across all court levels and drew 360 responses; the number of judges approached and the response rate are not given.
- About 80% of responding judges handling civil, family and administrative cases say they have seen false or non-existent decisions cited.
- The court administration says the civil and criminal procedure codes need amending to create a legal basis, notably for a fine, and will consult the Ministry of Justice before advising the National Assembly.
- The communiqué sets no amount, timetable or sanctioning authority for the proposed fine.
- Other courts have already dealt with such filings: a US $5,000 penalty in 2023, a UK Divisional Court judgment in 2025 restating the range of possible sanctions, and a 200-euro fine for abusive proceedings in Grenoble in 2026.

## What the Korean survey found

South Korea's National Court Administration has published the results of a survey on erroneous references produced by AI in court filings, as reported on 2 November 2026. According to the published results, the survey ran from 6 to 16 October among judges in all jurisdictions and collected 360 responses.

Roughly 80% of responding judges who handle civil, family and administrative cases say they have already seen citations of false or non-existent decisions. Among judges who answered the question on error types, 80.7% had seen a non-existent decision cited and 65.4% a distorted one.

One limit matters for reading these figures: the document does not state how many judges were approached or what the response rate was. The percentages therefore describe the respondents, and it is not possible to say from the facts provided how representative they are of the Korean judiciary.

## The proposed legal change

The institution considers it necessary to amend both the code of civil procedure and the code of criminal procedure in order to create a legal basis, notably for a fine. It says it will consult the Ministry of Justice before sending an opinion to the National Assembly.

The communiqué leaves the central questions open. It sets no amount, no timetable and no authority empowered to impose the fine. Who would be fined (lawyers, litigants or both), and for which kinds of filing, is not specified in the facts available.

## How other courts have responded

The Korean proposal comes after decisions in other jurisdictions, as listed in the same report.

- **United States:** on 22 June 2023, Judge P. Kevin Castel imposed a $5,000 penalty in *Mata v. Avianca* on two lawyers and their firm, under Rule 11 of the federal rules of civil procedure.
- **England and Wales:** on 6 June 2025, the Divisional Court of the High Court delivered the *Ayinde* judgment, which restated the range of possible sanctions. In the related Al-Haroun case, 18 of the 45 references submitted did not exist; the client had produced them with AI tools and the lawyer had repeated them without checking.
- **France:** on 4 June 2026, the Grenoble administrative court fined a litigant without a lawyer 200 euros for abusive proceedings, over a brief of more than 300 pages that it found manifestly AI-generated.

The text of the *Ayinde* judgment itself could not be used here: the PDF supplied by the judiciary is not readable as text, so the description above relies on the secondary report.

## The scale of the problem

As of 31 October 2026, a database maintained by Damien Charlotin lists 2,246 decisions worldwide dealing with the issue, including 1,517 in the United States, 14 in France and 8 in South Korea.

The Korean survey and the database count different things: one reports what responding judges say they have seen, the other lists recorded decisions. The facts provided do not allow a comparison between the two.

**Court decisions on AI-fabricated or abusive filings cited in the report** (data as of 2026-11-02)

| Date | Jurisdiction | Outcome |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 22 June 2023 | US federal court (Mata v. Avianca) | $5,000 penalty on two lawyers and their firm |
| 6 June 2025 | England and Wales (Divisional Court, Ayinde) | Judgment restating the range of possible sanctions |
| 4 June 2026 | Grenoble administrative court, France | 200-euro fine on a self-represented litigant for abusive proceedings |

## FAQ

### What does South Korea's court administration want?

It wants the civil and criminal procedure codes amended to create a legal basis, notably for a fine, against false AI-generated citations.

### How much would the fine be?

Not known. The communiqué sets no amount, timetable or sanctioning authority.

### How many judges answered the survey?

360 judges answered between 6 and 16 October. The number approached and the response rate are not stated.

## Sources

1. [La justice coréenne plaide pour une amende contre les faux arrêts de l'IA](https://www.actuia.com/actualite/la-justice-coreenne-plaide-pour-une-amende-contre-les-faux-arrets-de-lia/), ActuIA, 2026-11-02
2. [https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Ayinde-v-London-Borough-of-Haringey-and-Al-Haroun-v-Qatar-National-Bank.pdf](https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Ayinde-v-London-Borough-of-Haringey-and-Al-Haroun-v-Qatar-National-Bank.pdf), judiciary.uk, 2025-06-06 (primary source)
